An Old Fashioned is a simple cocktail, which means every ingredient is noticeable. Bourbon, sugar, bitters and a small amount of water have nowhere to hide. The right bourbon should provide enough flavor to remain central while still allowing the bitters and citrus garnish to contribute. We’re proud to carry the best bourbons for Old Fashioned cocktails at Jacques Scott Wines and Spirits.
Woodford Reserve
Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon is a classic option for an Old Fashioned because it’s known for flavors that can include spice, fruit, caramel and orange. Those flavors work naturally with aromatic bitters and an orange peel. The bourbon has enough presence to remain noticeable after stirring with ice, but it isn’t so aggressive that the drink becomes difficult to enjoy.
Start with a modest amount of sweetener. You can always add more, but you can’t easily remove it after the cocktail has been mixed. Woodford Reserve already brings rich flavors, so the drink shouldn’t need much sugar.
Bulleit Bourbon
Bulleit Bourbon has a relatively high rye content, which gives it a bolder, spicier character. It can produce an Old Fashioned with a drier, more energetic finish. This can be a good choice for drinkers who find some bourbon cocktails too sweet. The spice creates contrast with the sugar and works nicely with aromatic or orange bitters.
A simple orange peel is usually enough for garnish. There’s no need to add several pieces of fruit if you want the bourbon to remain the focus. Express the peel over the drink to release its oils, then place it in the glass.
Jim Beam Won’t Stretch The Party Budget
Jim Beam can be a practical choice when you’re making Old Fashioned cocktails for a larger gathering. A cocktail doesn’t always need the most expensive bottle available. Jim Beam can provide familiar bourbon flavor while allowing you to serve several guests at a manageable cost.
You can improve consistency by preparing a measured batch before the party. Combine the bourbon, bitters and sweetener, then refrigerate the mixture. Stir individual servings with ice or pour the chilled mixture over a large cube.
Bitters Can’t Be Treated Like Decoration
Bitters provide spice, aroma and complexity. Aromatic bitters are the standard choice, while orange bitters can strengthen the citrus character. Some drinkers use both. A few dashes are usually enough. Too much can make the cocktail medicinal or bitter. Keep the first version simple, then adjust future drinks based on what you liked.
An orange peel is the classic finishing touch. A cocktail cherry can be added, but it shouldn’t dominate the glass. You don’t need muddled fruit unless that’s the particular style you enjoy.
We Won’t Make Bourbon Shopping Confusing
Jacques Scott Wines and Spirits offers bourbon choices at different price points and with different flavor profiles. Tell us whether you prefer smooth, spicy, rich or affordable, and we’ll help narrow the options. You can shop at one of our convenient locations or order online. That makes it easier to purchase bourbon, bitters, mixers, and other party supplies without visiting multiple stores.
Your Old Fashioned Can’t Improve Without Balance
The best bourbons for Old Fashioned cocktails include rich Woodford Reserve, spicy Bulleit Bourbon and practical Jim Beam. Each creates a slightly different drink, but all can work when the sugar, bitters, water, and bourbon remain balanced. Jacques Scott Wines and Spirits, we’ll help you choose a bottle that matches your taste and budget. You don’t need complicated techniques. Find out more by calling +1 (345) 949-0277 or using our online form.
